Enhancing Women's Mobility and Safety: Addressing Challenges in Urban Transportation Systems

	Hari Srinivas
	GDRC Policy Trends D-017.

Introduction

As cities continue to grow, addressing these issues is essential for ensuring equitable mobility and empowering women to participate fully in economic, social, and civic life. This document explores the current state of urban transportation systems, the challenges faced by urban stakeholders, and policy options to create safer, more inclusive, and accessible transport networks for women.

Current State of Affairs

A primary challenge for many women is the safety aspect of using public transport, particularly in low-income or high-crime areas. Women are disproportionately affected by harassment and violence in public spaces, making it difficult for them to travel confidently or even access transportation services at all. This issue is compounded by limited public infrastructure in underserved areas, where women often face additional barriers, such as long distances to access bus or train stations. The lack of dedicated services for women or any measures to address these concerns means that many women rely on potentially unsafe or expensive alternatives, such as taxis or private ride-hailing services, to meet their transportation needs. Furthermore, last-mile connectivity poses a significant challenge, especially in areas outside city centers. Women are often responsible for a range of daily duties that involve drop-offs and pickups at schools, childcare centers, or healthcare facilities. Many urban transportation networks however fail to provide safe and efficient links to these critical locations. Poor integration of transport networks and insufficient provision of transport options for non-central locations exacerbate the issue, leaving women with limited choices to navigate daily life efficiently.

Challenges Faced by Urban Stakeholders

1. Inadequate Infrastructure for Women's Safety:

   One of the key challenges in urban transportation systems is the lack of infrastructure specifically designed with women's safety in mind. Public transport systems, such as buses, trains, and metro stations, often fail to incorporate safety features such as well-lit areas, surveillance cameras, and adequate security staff, which are crucial for ensuring a safe commuting experience.

   Many transport stations and buses are poorly lit at night, creating unsafe environments for female passengers, especially in less crowded areas. Furthermore, the absence of clear reporting mechanisms or staff trained to respond to harassment incidents makes it difficult for women to seek help or feel secure while traveling. In some cases, overcrowding, especially during peak hours, exacerbates these risks, leaving women vulnerable to unwanted attention or harassment.

2. Limited Accessibility to Public Transport:

   In many cities, women face barriers to accessing public transportation due to poor infrastructure or limited services in low-income or suburban areas. While major urban centers may have extensive transit networks, rural and outlying areas often suffer from inadequate or non-existent transport options. For women, who are more likely to undertake multiple roles-such as caregiving, working, and running household errands-public transport systems that fail to reach residential areas or key services such as hospitals and schools create significant hardships.

   Many women also rely on informal transport options, such as private taxis or ride-hailing services, which may not be affordable, reliable, or safe. For women with children or elderly family members, the lack of nearby public transport options can result in longer travel times and greater physical strain. Poorly integrated networks also limit the efficiency of travel, as the connections between different forms of transport (e.g., buses, trains, taxis) are often insufficient, forcing women to make complex and time-consuming transfers.

3. Harassment and Gender-based Violence:
   Harassment and gender-based violence are persistent problems that prevent many women from fully utilizing public transport systems. Women often experience physical, verbal, or sexual harassment on buses, trains, or in stations, especially in crowded environments where there is less space for personal security. This is particularly prevalent in high-density cities where overcrowding exacerbates the problem.

   Fear of harassment on public transport can deter women from using these systems, especially during late-night or early-morning hours when they are more likely to be alone. The lack of visible interventions, such as security patrols or the presence of female-only carriages, can make women feel vulnerable and unsafe.

   These experiences of harassment can lead to anxiety, stress, and the eventual avoidance of public transport altogether, forcing women to seek more expensive or less efficient alternatives. The impact of this issue extends beyond the immediate harm to women's safety, also restricting their independence and mobility, as they are discouraged from traveling freely in their communities.

4. Lack of Gender-sensitive Urban Planning:

   Urban transport systems often fail to consider the specific mobility patterns of women, who tend to have different travel needs compared to men. Women are more likely to engage in complex, multi-stop journeys, which include travel to work, schools, healthcare facilities, grocery stores, and other essential services. But transport planning in many cities has historically been designed around the needs of commuters who make direct, work-related trips, which typically occur during rush hours. Women's travel patterns, often more fragmented throughout the day, are overlooked in the design of transportation routes and schedules.

   Women's need for transport services during non-peak hours, such as early mornings or late evenings when they might be traveling for caregiving or after-school activities, is often ignored. The result is that many women face significant inconvenience, requiring longer travel times and greater physical exertion to accomplish their daily tasks. Furthermore, the failure to incorporate safety and accessibility features tailored to women's specific needs in urban planning means that even where transportation systems exist, they do not effectively serve female commuters.

5. Financial Constraints on Implementing Solutions:

   One of the greatest challenges urban stakeholders face in addressing these issues is financial constraints. Budget limitations often force city planners and transport authorities to prioritize large-scale infrastructure projects or initiatives that impact the general population, without giving adequate attention to the specific needs of women. Implementing gender-sensitive policies or infrastructure, such as safety measures, accessible routes, and better last-mile connectivity, requires substantial investment.

   Many cities face budgetary pressures and may struggle to allocate the necessary funds for such improvements, particularly in developing countries or low-income urban areas. The lack of political will or insufficient awareness of the importance of gender-sensitive transport systems can also result in inadequate funding for addressing women's mobility needs. As a result, urban transport systems may continue to neglect the safety, accessibility, and convenience of female commuters, perpetuating the challenges women face in cities.

Policy Options for Addressing Challenges

1. Enhancing Safety through Infrastructure and Technology: Implementing measures such as better street lighting, surveillance cameras, and security personnel at transport hubs can improve women's safety. Introducing apps or systems that allow women to report incidents and track their safety in real-time can also be crucial.

2. Improving Last-Mile Connectivity: Creating safe and affordable last-mile connections, such as shuttle services, bike-sharing programs, or pedestrian-friendly pathways, can increase accessibility for women, especially in under-served areas.

3. Establishing Gender-Sensitive Transport Planning: Policy-makers can focus on redesigning urban transport systems to include gender-specific needs, such as routes that cater to school and healthcare facilities, and ensuring that services are available during the early morning and late evening hours.

4. Addressing Harassment through Legal and Institutional Frameworks: Strengthening laws and policies against harassment on public transport and ensuring enforcement through training for staff and public awareness campaigns can contribute to a safer environment for women.

5. Increasing Funding for Gender-Inclusive Transport Solutions: Allocating specific budgetary funds for gender-sensitive infrastructure and policies can ensure that women's needs are prioritized in urban transportation planning and development.

Examples of Policy Options

1.	Enhancing Safety through Infrastructure and Technology:	In cities such as Tokyo, Japan, the introduction of female-only carriages during peak hours on subway trains has improved safety and comfort for women. Similarly, the implementation of real-time safety tracking apps in places such as Bogotó, Colombia, has allowed women to report harassment incidents and receive immediate assistance.
2.	Improving Last-Mile Connectivity:	In Nairobi, Kenya, the implementation of a bus-hailing service specifically designed to cater to women's routes has reduced travel times and provided safe, affordable transport options in underserved areas. This service also helps ensure the safe travel of children.
3.	Establishing Gender-Sensitive Transport Planning:	In cities such as Paris, France, authorities have worked to redesign public transport routes to better accommodate women's travel patterns, such as routes linking residential areas to key facilities such as schools, hospitals, and markets, improving accessibility and convenience.

Lessons Learnt

By addressing the specific needs of women in transportation planning, urban stakeholders can foster an environment that empowers women to travel safely, efficiently, and confidently. The policy options outlined above provide a framework for creating safer and more accessible transportation systems that serve the needs of women, contributing to the broader goal of gender equality in urban development.

The importance of this focus cannot be overstated, as it directly impacts women's quality of life and their ability to contribute to the social and economic vibrancy of cities.

This work by GDRC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. You are free to share and adapt this piece of work for your own purposes, as long as it is appropriately cited. More info: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ on

Hari Srinivas - hsrinivas@gdrc.org

Gender and Urban Development menu ▲  1. Designing Safe Urban Spaces  2. Enhancing Women's Mobility and Safety  3. Gender-Responsive Urban Infrastructure  4. Empowering Women through Urban Planning  5. Inclusive Urban Planning  6. Addressing Gender-Based Violence  7. Gender-Sensitive Urban Planning  Return to "Gender and Urban Development"

Hari Srinivas - hsrinivas@gdrc.org Return to Gender and Development